Kitchen Guide
“Non-toxic” and “PFAS-free” cookware: what the FTC's Green Guides say about such claims
Our take
When pans or air fryers are labeled non-toxic, PFAS-free or eco-friendly, the FTC's Green Guides say what such claims convey and what should back them.
By Review Boon Team · · 5 min read
Key points
- The FTC's Green Guides set out how the agency reads environmental marketing claims. They were last revised in 2012, and their text does not mention PFAS or cookware.
- A “non-toxic” claim likely means non-toxic for people and for the environment, the guides say, so a seller should have scientific evidence for both or a clear qualification.
- A true “free-of” claim can still mislead if the product contains substances with the same or similar environmental risks as the one left out.
- The guides say unqualified general claims such as “eco-friendly” should not be made, and, in one example, that a seal a maker awards itself is deceptive unless the ad clearly says so and limits the claim.
- The FTC opened a review of the guides in December 2022. Its Green Guides page still lists 2012 as the year of the latest revision.
Words such as “non-toxic,” “PFAS-free,” “PFOA-free” or “eco-friendly” on a nonstick pan, a ceramic-coated skillet or an air fryer basket are marketing claims. The Federal Trade Commission's Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims, known as the Green Guides, set out how the agency thinks shoppers understand claims like these and what a seller should be able to prove. They are published at 16 CFR part 260. The FTC says they were first issued in 1992 and revised in 1996, 1998 and 2012.
The text of the guides does not mention PFAS or cookware. What follows is the general approach the FTC takes to such claims, not a ruling on any product or label.
What the guides are, and what they are not
The guides state the FTC's current views and are meant to help marketers avoid claims that are unfair or deceptive under Section 5 of the FTC Act. They do not bind the agency or the public. The FTC can still bring a case if a marketer makes an environmental claim inconsistent with them, and in that case it must prove that the practice is unfair or deceptive. The guides apply to labels, advertising and every other form of marketing, and a claim can be made through words, symbols, logos, pictures or a brand name.
They also leave other laws in place. The guides do not preempt federal, state or local laws, and complying with those laws does not necessarily rule out FTC action, they say. State laws on PFAS in cookware are covered in our guide to the Minnesota, Colorado and Maine bans.
What “non-toxic” promises
The guides treat “non-toxic” as a broad claim. In the FTC's view, it likely tells consumers that a product is non-toxic both for humans and for the environment generally. A marketer should therefore have competent and reliable scientific evidence for both, or qualify the claim clearly and prominently. The guides' example is a cleaning product advertised as “essentially non-toxic” that poses no risk to people but is toxic to the environment: the claim would be deceptive.
The standard of proof behind that is high. For environmental claims, the guides say, a reasonable basis often requires competent and reliable scientific evidence: tests, analyses, research or studies carried out and evaluated objectively by qualified people. In our reading, a pan sold as “non-toxic” is making a claim about its effects on people and on the wider environment, not only about cooking with it.
“PFAS-free,” “PFOA-free” and other “free-of” claims
A separate section covers claims that a product is free of a substance, or does not contain or use it. Misrepresenting that is deceptive, and the guides describe two ways a true claim can still mislead. The first is when the product contains or uses substances that pose the same or similar environmental risks as the one that is absent. The second is when the absent substance has not been associated with that kind of product.
In our reading, the first test bears on labels that name a single chemical as absent: on its own, such a label says nothing about related chemicals. Whether a particular label misleads depends on its facts.
The guides do allow a free-of claim for a product that contains a trace amount, depending on the context, if three conditions are met: the level is no more than an acknowledged trace contaminant or background level, its presence does not cause the material harm consumers typically associate with the substance, and the substance was not added intentionally.
“Eco-friendly,” “green” and seals
Broad claims get the strictest treatment. The guides say marketers should not make unqualified general environmental benefit claims, which likely suggest far-reaching benefits, or no negative environmental impact at all, that a marketer is highly unlikely to be able to prove. Their example is a product with the brand name “Eco-friendly,” which they call deceptive. A qualified version such as “Eco-friendly: made with recycled materials” would not be, provided the qualifier is clear and prominent, the whole product apart from minor, incidental components is made from recycled material, that makes the product better for the environment overall, and the rest of the ad implies nothing misleading.
Seals and certification logos can be endorsements. A seal that does not convey the basis for the certification, through its name or some other means, likely conveys a general environmental benefit, so the guides say marketers should not use such seals. In one of their examples, a paint maker that awards a seal to its own product, with no independent certifier involved, makes a deceptive claim, because the seal suggests independent certification and far-reaching benefits. The claim would not be deceptive, the guides add, with clear, prominent wording that the maker awarded the seal and that it covers only specific, limited benefits. The guides also say a claim should make clear whether it refers to the product, its packaging or only part of either.
How the FTC has enforced “free” claims
The FTC's 2017 paint cases show how it has handled free-of claims. On July 11, 2017, it announced settlements with four paint companies, Benjamin Moore, ICP Construction, YOLO Colorhouse and Imperial Paints, over claims that their paints were emission-free or contained zero volatile organic compounds (VOCs). The FTC alleged that the companies had no evidence to support those claims, some of which also said the paints were safe for babies and other sensitive groups.
After a public comment period, the FTC approved final consent orders on April 27, 2018. They bar the four from unqualified emission-free or VOC-free claims unless a paint's content and emissions are zero at all times from application onward, or its emissions stay at trace levels as the orders define them. That definition, the FTC said in 2017, generally tracks the Green Guides' trace amount test. In its complaints against Benjamin Moore and ICP Construction, the FTC also alleged that the companies used environmental seals without disclosing that they had awarded the seals to their own products.
Where the FTC's review stands
The FTC opened a review of the guides on December 14, 2022, voting 4-0 to seek public comment. The specific issues it expected to draw many comments were carbon offsets and climate change, the term “recyclable,” recycled content, and whether to add guidance on claims such as “compostable,” “degradable,” “ozone-friendly,” “organic” and “sustainable.” That list did not single out free-of or non-toxic claims. The agency also scheduled a workshop on recyclable claims for May 23, 2023.
On November 15, 2026, the FTC's Green Guides page still listed 2012 as the year of the latest revision, and the 2026 edition of the Code of Federal Regulations, revised as of January 1, 2026, carries the guides with the 2012 Federal Register notice as their source. Shoppers who believe a claim misled them can report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. The FTC says it does not resolve individual complaints, but that reports help law enforcement detect patterns.
Based on 16 CFR part 260 (2026 edition) and the FTC pages listed below, all read on November 15, 2026. This guide assesses no product, label or company.
Sources
- 16 CFR part 260, Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims (revised as of January 1, 2026) Federal Trade Commission (Code of Federal Regulations, via GovInfo), January 1, 2026
- Environmentally Friendly Products: FTC's Green Guides Federal Trade Commission, November 15, 2026
- FTC Seeks Public Comment on Potential Updates to its ‘Green Guides’ for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims Federal Trade Commission, December 14, 2022
- Paint Companies Settle FTC Charges That They Misled Consumers; Claimed Products Are Emission- and VOC-free and Safe for Babies and other Sensitive Populations Federal Trade Commission, July 11, 2017
- FTC Approves Final Consent Orders Settling Charges that Four Paint Companies Misled Consumers through Claims Their Products are Emission- and VOC-Free Federal Trade Commission, April 27, 2018
- Solving Problems with a Business: Returns, Refunds, and Other Resolutions Federal Trade Commission (Consumer Advice), September 2024
Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then checked against the 6 sources above in a separate fact-check on November 15, 2026. Spotted an error? Tell us.