Review Boon

Home and tech products, reviewed

Smart Home

Most smart product users with a problem reported no harm, research for UK product safety office finds

Our take

Two reports the UK's Office for Product Safety and Standards published on November 17 cover harms and risk attitudes for smart speakers, doorbells and TVs.

By Review Boon Team · · 4 min read

Key points

  • In a March 2026 survey of 497 UK adults who picked a smart product they had had an issue with, 62% reported no harm from it, according to research published by OPSS on November 17.
  • Smart doorbell users were the least likely of the four most-named product groups to report no harm: 44%, against 66% for smart TVs and 72% for smart speakers.
  • A second report, comparing surveys from 2023, 2025 and 2026, found average benefit ratings for 10 smart products rose from 4.1 to 4.8 out of 7, while worry slipped from 3.8 to 3.5.
  • Both reports say their views are the authors' and not necessarily those of OPSS or government policy. Neither changes any rule.

The UK's Office for Product Safety and Standards (OPSS) published two research reports on smart home products on Tuesday, November 17, 2026. Both were commissioned by OPSS and prepared by Professor Magda Osman, a research fellow at the University of Cambridge Judge Business School, and each says its views are the authors', not necessarily those of OPSS or government policy.

The first report finds that most people who had a problem with a smart product reported no harm from it. The second, which repeated a 2023 survey in 2025 and 2026, finds that people rated the products' benefits more highly over time while their worries eased only slightly.

What users who had a problem reported

In the harms report's second survey, run online in March 2026 with 497 UK adults, respondents chose a smart product they had had an issue with in the previous 12 months and said which harms, if any, it had caused. Smart TVs were the most common choice, at 28% of the products named, ahead of smart speakers (21%), smart doorbells (10.7%) and smart watches (7.8%). The report says 98% of participants described an issue with the product they chose.

Overall, 62% reported no harm. Psychological harm, which the survey defined as a negative effect on well-being lasting more than a few days, was reported by 19%. Financial harm, meaning costs of dealing with a problem the product caused, was reported by 13% in the report's results table, while its summary puts the figure at 18%.

Share of respondents reporting each outcome for the four most-named products, March 2026 survey (harms report, Table 13, selected rows; figures as published).
OutcomeSmart TV (155)Smart speaker (116)Smart doorbell (59)Smart watch (43)
No harm66%72%44%70%
Psychological harm16%17%29%26%
Financial harm17%8%17%9%
Physical harm0%0%3%5%
Property damage0%2%3%0%

Doorbells also stood out in the report's first survey, which asked about harms people expected rather than ones they had experienced. The report warns that its definition of psychological harm leaves a lot open to interpretation, and that the findings on it need to be treated with caution.

What people expected, and what they want a regulator to do

That first survey, of 1,464 people in July and August 2025, asked about harms during a year of owning smart products, under normal use, a malfunction or an internet security breach; each person rated five of 15 products. Between 21% and 22% judged that each of the four harms it asked about would occur at least once, and people who knew a product well expected fewer harms. The highest figures were for property damage from a malfunctioning smart drill (60%) or smart vacuum cleaner (58%).

Asked what a regulator should do about a harm, the 2025 respondents most often chose removing the product from the market (36%) or fining the company (30%), ahead of warning labels (21%) and public campaigns (13%). The 2026 survey added the option of collecting more evidence, and it became the most common answer (43%), followed by removal from the market (21%).

Benefits up, worries little changed

The second report compares three online surveys of UK adults, from 2023, 2025 and 2026, in which people rated the same 10 smart products, among them speakers, doorbells, door locks and robot vacuums, on scales of 1 to 7. Five more products, including smart glasses, a smart oven and a smart smoke detector, were added in 2025.

Average ratings across the 10 products asked about in all three surveys, on a scale of 1 to 7 (risk tolerance report, Table 4).
Rating202320252026
Personal benefit4.14.34.8
Familiarity4.14.14.6
Expected frequency of use4.74.85.3
Worry about risks3.83.63.5
Concern about data use4.13.93.8
Weighing risks when buying4.44.14.1

The report says the survey year had only a very weak effect on most ratings, and that the clearest change was in perceived benefits. It concludes that the growing tolerance of smart product risks is “largely with respect to perceiving greater benefits from them rather than dramatic reductions in concerns.” A teddy bear camera and a connected robot toy for children drew the most concern of the 10 products in all three surveys. Smart glasses were the exception among the newer products: from 2025 to 2026, both their perceived benefits and the concerns about them rose.

The rules already in place

The reports are research and do not change any rules. Since April 29, 2024, the UK's product security regime has required passwords on consumer connectable products to be unique to each product or set by the user, and makers to say how security problems can be reported and to publish a minimum period of security updates with an end date, according to government guidance that names OPSS as the enforcer. Our guide to software update periods compares that rule with the FCC's voluntary U.S. label.

The harms report adds that even where smart products rarely cause harm, the problems people describe mean businesses need to make sure products work as advertised and that customer service deals with problems promptly. All the surveys covered UK adults only, recruited online through the Prolific platform.

Sources

  1. Experiences of harms from smart products in the home Office for Product Safety and Standards (GOV.UK), November 17, 2026
  2. Experiences of harms from smart products in the home: report (PDF, dated August 2026) Office for Product Safety and Standards (GOV.UK), November 17, 2026
  3. Tolerance of risks from products with internet connectivity Office for Product Safety and Standards (GOV.UK), November 17, 2026
  4. UK Public's Tolerance of Risks from Products with Internet Connectivity in the Home (Smart Products) (PDF, dated August 2026) Office for Product Safety and Standards (GOV.UK), November 17, 2026
  5. The UK Product Security and Telecommunications Infrastructure (Product Security) regime Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (GOV.UK), May 2, 2024

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then checked against the 5 sources above in a separate fact-check on November 18, 2026. Spotted an error? Tell us.